In this article, we will break down the sentence ‘It is a mystery that who painted this picture’ and examine its grammatical correctness. We’ll also provide clear examples and tips on how to improve sentence construction for clarity and fluency in English.
1. Is the Original Sentence Correct?
The sentence ‘It is a mystery that who painted this picture’ is not grammatically correct in English. The use of ‘that’ in combination with ‘who’ creates redundancy and confusion. In English, the structure of this sentence should be revised to make it clearer.
2. Corrected Version: What Should It Be?
The correct way to express the idea is: ‘It is a mystery who painted this picture.’ By removing the word ‘that’, the sentence flows more naturally, and the question word ‘who’ introduces the unknown subject in the sentence.
Alternatively, you can say: ‘Who painted this picture is a mystery.’ Both forms are grammatically correct and convey the same meaning.
3. Understanding Sentence Structure
In English, when you want to express something unknown or a question in a statement form, you typically use question words (who, what, where, etc.) without ‘that’. For example:
- ‘It is unclear who will attend the meeting.’
- ‘The question is where they went.’
In these cases, the sentence structure does not need an additional ‘that’ before the question word.
4. Examples of Correct and Incorrect Usage
Here are more examples to illustrate the correct usage:
| Incorrect | Correct |
|---|---|
| ‘It is a mystery that who took the book.’ | ‘It is a mystery who took the book.’ |
| ‘I don’t know that what time the event starts.’ | ‘I don’t know what time the event starts.’ |
5. Final Tips on Improving English Sentence Structure
To avoid confusion in sentence construction, it’s important to remember the following:
- When expressing a question or unknown in a declarative sentence, use ‘who’, ‘what’, ‘where’, etc., without ‘that’.
- Simplify the sentence by focusing on the main subject and verb to make your message clearer.
- Practice rephrasing sentences that sound awkward or redundant for better fluency.
6. Conclusion
To summarize, ‘It is a mystery that who painted this picture’ is incorrect. The correct sentence is ‘It is a mystery who painted this picture.’ By making small adjustments, you can greatly improve sentence clarity and grammar in English. Keep practicing these tips for smoother, more natural communication!
コメント